Tuesday, October 26, 2010

Ethnography and Game Studies

I think that Boellstorff brings up some interesting points in his article about ethnography and game studies. In his article, he briefly unpacks the meaning of “participant observation” and its inherent oxymoron – “that you cannot participate and fully observe at the same time.” He states that it is within this paradox that anthropologists do their best work. He explains that participant observation implies a critical engagement that blurs the line between the researcher and the researched and that it is a method based on failure and learning from mistakes.

I think that it is very useful that he frames this method as a method based on failure. If you are going to study something that is unpredictable and complex, it helps to be unafraid of ambiguities, to be able to keep a steady pace without pausing too long in hesitation at potential bumps in the road. It has always seemed to me that games were a better metaphor for life than other types of art that are commonly thought of as imitations of life (film, music, drawings, etc.)

Games are so dependent on experience and engagement that they do not even seem to exist without participation. When a researcher takes it upon themselves to study a game, they must truly go down the rabbit hole – if they do not immerse themselves then they will not really be studying the heart of the game (which consists experience, involvement, action and reaction, emotion, and other human dimensions). They will merely be looking at superficial elements such as the graphics or the mechanics, and therefore might as well be studying a drawing or car. I think that it is important to make this distinction between games and other types of media.

I also think it is interesting how Boellstorff differentiates between three types of game studies: 1) game cultures, 2) cultures of gaming, and 3) the gaming of cultures. In Boellstorff’s description, each level of gaming study seems to broaden the scope of the game studies field. His description very much convinces me that the field of game studies in a complex, multi-level research area that deserves more attention.

I myself do not play any games and cannot claim particular awareness of the first category of gaming research, i.e. “game cultures.” I don’t think I can easily become familiar with a game culture unless I played myself (participant observation). However, I can easily relate to “cultures of gaming” and the “gaming of cultures” because these domains exist in the physical world, and I can also see them at play in my own life with respect to friends and colleagues who do play games. I think that there is an assumption that the only people who would want to study games are those who play themselves, but from Boellstorff’s explanation of the two other ways that gaming can be studied, I can see that anyone with an interest in culture (and not necessarily specific games) would be wise to consider game studies as an area for intellectual study.

Commodification of Academic Research

I just came across this interview with Hans Radder, a Dutch academic, on the commodification of academic research. Figured some of you might be interested.

Monday, October 25, 2010

Ethnographic challenges

This week's reading and today's class discussion has raised a lot of questions and challenges for me in terms of conducting my own research, although that is by no means a negative thing.
For instance, when we were discussing the difference between passive and covert observation, that got me thinking: which one would be applicable in an international context? For instance, if I mean to study the link between religion, politics and access to information in a traditional patriarchal society like Egypt, I'm going to have to study Al-Azhar in-depth or else my study is incomplete. Al-Azhar is by no means co-ed, and not to downplay the female section but the male section is where all the scholarly and political action is (unfortunately). So it got me thinking: how do I get in? I can't just "hang out" in a casual manner, nor can I sit in a corner taking notes. What is a way of overcoming this hurdle that doesn't involve disguising as a man or getting a spy-for-hire to observe and report back to you? Should I forget about first-hand observation all together and just rely on formal interviews? Interviews are no match for observing someone in their natural setting; people just aren't being completely 'themselves' when they are being interviewed. But I won't give up just yet, and all suggestions are welcome!

Sunday, October 24, 2010

What I am looking at is actually "Why" but not "What"

Weeks ago when we were talking about "Focus Group" research method, I was struggling and debating with myself -- when I was doing my undergrad Management courses, one of my professors were strongly opposed to the idea of "Focus Group" in general and university students as sampling in particular. I bought in his idea that "focus group" with inappropariated sampling will lead to "group think", which will result in strongly bias. Therefore, within the past two weeks I kept struggling with myself on the sampling scope issues. Finally I have seen the light from Lucker's Field (and Other) Methods chapter. As Luker (2008) mentioned, "Regardless of whether things happened the way people said they did, what interests us is that people chose to tell us that they happend that way. Interviews are, almost by definition, accurate accounts of the kinds of mental maps that people carry around inside their heads, ad that it is this, rather than some videotape of "reality", which is of interest to us" (167). So what I should be looking at is not about what the interviewees have said, but rather why they would choose to say so. In this way, even there is a group think, by looking at the process for them to come up with the similar answers I can actually identify the social pattern thus locate the issues or conflicts.
Besides, Luker interview question design is also insightful to me. In my preliminary research project, I have designed to interview several senior managerial staff of my research subject organization. Now that I have read Luker's interview questions, I will have to redesign my own questions so as to make them lead my interviewees to the issues of the organization that they might not aware of or would not be willing to address unless I ask.

Thursday, October 21, 2010

Let's take a poll....

Bill O'Reilly, in his now notorious appearance on "The View," cited a poll that said 70% of Americans were against building a mosque two blocks away from Ground Zero.
I have only recently started to question quantitative research findings, since we began INF1240. How many times have we come across so-called 'research findings' in the news, newspapers, magazines, and actually asked ourselves, "How did they come up with this data? What questions did they ask? How many people did they sample? What was their margin of error?" Anyone reading this blog entry can easily come up with ten more questions.
The poll O'Reilly was referring to is an opinion research poll conducted by CNN:
CNN interviewed 1009 people over the phone. They felt that number was sufficient enough to issue a definitive statement that 70% of over 300,000,000 Americans opposed the mosque. Should the survey have asked them to list reasons for their answer? Does it matter what their reasons are? How much time did the respondents take to actually think about what the 41 questions were asking? Is it possible the questions were designed to illicit negative responses? Personally, I know if I'm forced to take a phone survey characterized by such long-winded questions, I respond mindlessly without thinking about what the question is really asking. I think, "Who cares? It's just a survey. I just want to get off the phone."
But to Bill O'Reilly and (judging by the thunderous applause he received and the video comments on YouTube) to many others, it is not just a survey. It amounts to rhetorical ammunition.
Guess the moral of the story is: never underestimate the power of a CNN poll.

Wednesday, October 20, 2010

Rare Disease Patients and Privacy Risk

It wasn't until I read Luker's chapter for this week and saw a guest presentation in INF1001 that I came to a conclusion regarding my sample – assuming it actually is a conclusion. Following a guest lecture in INF1001 regarding the social networking website for patients called patientslikeme.com, it sort of hit me. I've consistently been struggling with an exciting “place” online where I could carry out research regarding the relationship between altruism and personal revelation. I think I may have found it. Patientslikeme.com is an extremely interesting website that encourages patients of varying diseases to share their medical history. That data is stored, analysis on that data is done via some algorithm, and then shared with the community in an attempt to better understand diagnoses, symptoms, and treatments of similar patients.


The interesting part is that the community tends to be more or less split up into two halves: those with common diseases and those with rare diseases. Each user has a profile, which takes quite a long time to fill out. Additionally, each profile consists of modules, which are meant to be filled out over time and with varying granularity. What I'm principally interested in is whether patients with rare diseases, in relation to those with common diseases, divulge more information more often – I would do my best to sample either population according to available statistics. The “so what” of this is to, as my hypothesis would suggest, potentially find that rare disease patients are more likely to participate in personal revelation in an attempt of empathetic altruism. In other words, they understand the systemic limitations of rare disease diagnoses and treatment. Perhaps a greater knowledge base could mitigate some of these failures. In addition, and most importantly, what that could suggest is that those on the margins of the “disease-occurrence spectrum” are at greater risk of personal privacy exploitation. Additionally, risk analysis could be extremely useful in such a study.

Monday, October 18, 2010

Research for the sake of research?

After this weeks readings --- experiment, quasi-experiment, sampling, confidence intervals, control groups, generalizations, surveys, pilot testing, I am in full data overload. Reserach on research methods, ethnography, small populations, niche populations, general populations, the list goes on. My head is spinning and yet at peace. Now, I completely understand more than ever that there is nothing... no sacred topic, nothing too small, nothing too big... that cannot in some fashion be brought to study. It is what seems to make the world go round. So this afternoon, I took to the newspaper and made a concerted effort to see how many front page news items were related to some research paper that has just come out --- the answer.... of the 3 front page news items....2 were directly related to presenting research facts. It's quite simply everywhere!! And so, no matter if my SSHRC is accepted or if I go on to do my thesis, these valuable methods if nothing else will help me enjoy and dissect the Saturday paper with coffee.